WikiWise | What it's like to become non-Notable; WMF speaks on NYT v Open AI suit

People who have had their Wikipedia articles deleted share their stories with Wired and the Wikimedia Foundation inserts itself into a big AI fight. 

A cursor choosing between yes or no

🔔 Wiki Briefing

When Wikipedia biographies disappear: No such thing as bad publicity, but what about no publicity? 

When there are 27 Wikipedia articles per active editor, things slip through the cracks, but most will be caught with time. 

The encyclopedia recently surpassed 7 million articles on English Wikipedia, but it estimates that there are only about 260,000 users who made an edit in the last month. The self-governed site has penned a vast corpus of rules and guidelines over the last 25 years, including outlining which topics get their own article, otherwise known as Notability.

The rules are tighter for living people. There is a whole ruleset for writing about living people in order to avoid misinformation, privacy issues, and libel. It's no surprise when biographies teetering on the edge of meeting notability criteria find themselves the focus of a deletion conversation.

Wired caught up with several people whose articles were removed. A common through line between them lands on available news coverage and accusations of self-promotion. Sourcing is the deciding factor in how Wikipedia is written. If the reliability of references isn't up to snuff, or if the Wikipedia articles and their sources seem too much like advertisements, it isn't a matter of if but when editors sniff out a non-notable topic.

The solution sounds easy: don't publish articles using bad sourcing. However, interpreting source quality is subjective. If you want a Wikipedia article to stick, take a deep dive into understanding reliable sources and how they establish notability. Similarly, if you disagree with the deletion of an article, new reliable sources could be the thing you need. Don't be afraid to collaborate by engaging on the Talk page or, for new topics, submitting a draft for review rather than publishing it right away. And when you are creating a biography for yourself, your boss, or someone who leads your company, seeking review from others isn't up for debate, it is mandatory.


📰 In the News

Wikimedia Foundation weighs in on New York Times v OpenAI

The Wikimedia Foundation spoke up on the 2023 lawsuit filed by The New York Times against OpenAI and Microsoft in the form of an amicus brief submitted by the nonprofit in late October.

The suit focuses on the information AI companies use to train models. OpenAI and Microsoft get their information from a variety of sources, including the NYT, which the newspaper's lawyers say violates copyright laws. The opposition argues otherwise: the information falls under "fair use" protection since it is public and being used for technological development.

The Wikimedia logo in a courtroom

While the Times may have a run of the mill copyright argument, the WMF does not. Content on all of its sites, including Wikipedia, is released under a Creative Commons license—as long as there is credit, anyone can use it. Editors on the site have their own rules to keep copyrighted material out of the online encyclopedia.

Editors on Wikipedia have a long history of opposition to artificial intelligence and LLMs. The Foundation has been less outspoken, but not mum. A year ago, the WMF started tightening the reins on bot scraping by offering companies access to its data through the Wikimedia Enterprise platform, rather than with general traffic. At the time, the WMF estimated that 65% of the most server-straining traffic came from bot scraping.

If copyright isn't a concern for the Foundation, then what is? Access to information. On the side against AI companies, a favorable ruling could harm "the flow of knowledge between human authors and audiences.” But the NYT point of view strengthens copyright holders and their ability to withhold access to knowledge even in cases of the innovative and transformative, which is part of what fair use laws cover.

Either way, the ruling will impact the online encyclopedia, and its overseers seem to want it to find a middle ground. One thing is clear: the Foundation wants to be in the fight for open knowledge.


📚 Research Report

Researchers find out how much cleaning up Wikipedia editors need to do

Researchers at Johns Hopkins University asked a simple question: How Grounded is Wikipedia? Their paper in Findings of the Association for Computational Linguistics looks at how much Wikipedia content is verified by sources. 

The paper specifically investigated whether claims made in an article's lead are supported by the body and if claims in the article's body are supported by sources. Researchers looked at data from 1,500 biographies, analysing 50,000 claims in the introduction and 100,000 claims in the article body.

When it came to the lead, they found 22% were unsupported by the article's body, and for facts claimed in the body of an article, 30% were unsupported. But that latter number isn't without its caveats: researchers looked at if those claims were supported by publicly accessible, digital sources. Not all sources on Wikipedia fall into this category; subscription or offline publications can be a reliable source.

But as readers now know, it isn't a matter of if but when editors will eventually sniff out these discrepancies.


🧩 Wikipedia Facts

Wikipedia has a newspaper! The Signpost is a community-authored newspaper that's perfect for anyone who just can't get their fill of encyclopedia news through WikiWise.


💡 Tips & Tricks

Did you know you can find out traffic figures for any Wikipedia article? To find it, start by clicking on the "View history" link at the top of an article. Then click on "Pageviews" in the external tools section near the top. It's that simple!

Next
Next

WikiWise | AI bots target Wikipedia